A Psychological-Cultural Examination of the Barriers to the Formation of Peasant Uprisings in Iran (From the Onset of the Safavid Era to the Land Reforms of 1963)

Document Type : Research Paper I Open Access I Released under (CC BY-NC 4.0) license

Authors

1 Master's student of Political Science, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh Tabatabae’i University, Tehran, Iran.

2 Assistant Professor of Political Science, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Law and Social Sciences, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran.

3 Professor of Political Science, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh Tabatabae’i University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

This article employs to Psychological-Cultural examine the barriers to the formation of peasant uprisings in Iran, spanning from the Safavid period to the land reforms of 1963. This study proposes a multi-level framework that analyzes the factors influencing this phenomenon at individual, collective, cultural, and structural levels. The framework is grounded in concepts such as learned helplessness and everyday resistance, the absence of collective self-efficacy and social identity, traumatic historical memory and religious legitimation, as well as entrenched obedient identities within socio-economic structures. The findings indicate that factors such as fear and learned helplessness have directed peasants toward everyday resistance rather than uprising, thereby institutionalizing a belief in the futility of protest within their mindset; religious narratives, incorporating elements like fatalism, have served to justify and legitimize the existing order; geographical dispersion has limited the potential for solidarity and shared class identity; and the landlord-peasant structure, coupled with patriarchal systems, has internalized the prevailing order, thereby impeding the emergence of peasant movements. By presenting a multifaceted psychological model through a historical-analytical method and drawing on library-based sources, this research offers a fresh perspective on Iran's political-social history, fills the gap in psychological analyses in this domain, and contributes to a deeper understanding of the dynamics of Iran's political history during this period.

Keywords

Main Subjects


   

 

This is an open access article distributed under the following Creative Commons license: Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0)

  1.  

    1. Ābrāhāmīān, Y. (1398). Tārīkh-e Īrān-e modern (M. E. Fattāḥī, Trans.). Tehran: Nashr-e Nī.
    2. Ābrāhāmīān, Y. (1400). Maqālātī dar jāme‘e-shenāsī-ye sīyāsī-ye Īrān (S. T. Fārsānī, Trans.). Tehran: Shirāze Ketāb-e Mā.
    3. Āl-Aḥmad, J. (1370). Tāt neshinhā-ye Bolūk-e Zahra. Tehran: Amīrkabīr.
    4. Estavār, M. (1396). Enqelāb-e Eslāmī va nabard-e namādhā. Tehran: Negāh-e Mo‘āser.
    5. Eskandar Beyg Meneshī. (1377). ‘Ālam-ārā-ye ‘Abbāsī (M. E. Rezvānī, Ed.), 3 vols. Tehran: Donyā-ye Ketāb.
    6. Ashraf, A. (1359). Mavāne‘-e tārīkhī-ye roshd-e sarmāye-gārī dar Īrān-e dowr-e Qājārīye. Tehran: Zamineh.
    7. Ashraf, A., & ‘Alī Banu-‘Azīzī. (1388). Tabāqat-e ejtemā‘ī, dowlat va enqelāb dar Īrān (S. T. Fārsānī, Trans.). Tehran: Nīlūfar.
    8. Bāzargān, M. (1346). Sāzgārī-ye Irānī. Tehran: Payām-e Āzādī.
    9. Bāstānī Pārīzī, M. E. (1378). Siyāsat va eqtesād-e ‘Asr-e Safavī. Tehran: Safī ‘Alīshāh.
    10. Badī‘, B. (1380). Do Dowlat: Qodrat va jāme‘e dar Gharb va dar Sarzamin-hā-ye Eslāmī (A. Naqībzādeh, Trans.). Tehran: Markaz-e Bāzshenāsī-ye Eslām va Īrān.
    11. Barzegar, E. (1402). Ravān-shenāsī-ye sīyāsī. Tehran: Sāzmān-e Motāle‘e va Tadvin-e Kotob-e Dāneshgāhī dar ‘Olūm-e Eslāmī va Ensānī (Samt).
    12. Bashīrīye, H. (1380). Mavāne‘-e towse‘e-ye sīyāsī dar Īrān. Tehran: Gām-e No.
    13. Bashīrīye, H. (1400). Jāme‘e-shenāsī-ye sīyāsī. Tehran: Nashr-e Nī.
    14. Bentesco, F. (1347). “Nosāzī-ye zendegī-ye rūstā’ī va dāmparvarī dar manteqe-ye Zāgros.” Nāmeh-ye ‘Olūm-e Ejtemā‘ī, 1(1), 121–141.
    15. Parker, I., & Pawson-Quellar, D. (1402). Ravān-kavī va enqelāb: Ravān-shenāsī-ye enteqādī barāye jonbesh-hā-ye āzādī-bakhsh (M. Taqī-Ābādī, Trans.). Tehran: Sīb-e Sorkh.
    16. Tāj-bakhsh, A. (1340). Īrān dar dowr-e Safavī. Tabriz: Enteshārāt-e Ketābforūshī Chehr.
    17. Tafazzolī, A. (1376). “Dehqān.” (A. Khatībī, Trans.) Nāmeh-ye Farhangestān, 3(1), 155–148.
    18. Khosravī, K. (1358). Jāme‘e-shenāsī-ye rūstā-ye Īrān. Tehran: Payām.
    19. Khwāja Naṣīr al-Dīn Ṭūsī. (1360). Akhlāq-e Nāṣerī (M. Mīnuvī & A. Ḥeydari, Eds.). Tehran: Khvārazmī.
    20. Delavāleh, P. (1384). Safar-nāmeh-ye Pietro Delavāleh (Sh. al-Dīn Shafā, Trans.). Tehran: ‘Elmi va Farhangī.
    21. Delāvarī, A. (1390). Jāme‘e-shenāsī-ye tahavvolāt-e Īrān: az Enqelāb-e Mashruteh tā Qiyām-e Khordād 1342. Tehran: Pazhūheshkadeh-ye Emām Khomeinī va Enqelāb-e Eslāmī.
    22. Rāvandī, M. (1356). Tārīkh-e ejtemā‘ī-ye Īrān, 2. Tehran: Amīrkabīr.
    23. Rāvandī, M. (1357). Tārīkh-e ejtemā‘ī-ye Īrān, 3. Tehran: Amīrkabīr.
    24. Rāvandī, M. (1976). Tārīkh-e ejtemā‘ī-ye Īrān, 9. Stockholm, Sweden: Āresh Publications.
    25. Rezāqolī, ‘Alī. (1400). Jāme‘e-shenāsī-ye khodkāmgī. Tehran: Nashr-e Nī.
    26. Sā‘edlū, H. (1357). Masā’el-e keshāvarzī-ye Īrān. Tehran: Rovāq.
    27. Sharī‘atī, ‘Alī. (1351). Tashī‘-e ‘Alawī va Tashī‘-e Safavī. Tehran: Sepideh Bāvarān.
    28. Safī-nejād, J. (1353). Boneh (Nezamhā-ye tolīd-e zarā‘ī-ye jam‘ī qabl va ba‘d az eslāḥāt-e arżī), 3. Tehran: Tūs.
    29. Tabarī, E. (1396). Barkhī barrasī-hā pirāmūn-e jahān-bīnī-hā va jonbesh-hā-ye ejtemā‘ī dar Īrān (A. Alīzādeh, Ed.). Tehran: Ferdows.
    30. ‘Alamdārī, K. (1392). Cherā Īrān ‘Aqeb mand va Gharb pīsh raft? Tehran: Towse‘e.
    31. ‘Īsawī, C. (1362). Tārīkh-e eqtesādī-ye Īrān (Dowr-e Qājār, 1215–1332 H.Q.) (Y. Ājand, Trans.). Tehran: Gostareh.
    32. Farāstukhāh, M. (1401). Mā Irānīyān. Tehran: Nashr-e Nī.
    33. Farhādī, M. (1394). Farhang-e yārigarī dar Īrān: Daramadī-ye mardom-shenāsī va jāme‘e-shenāsī-ye ta‘āvon. Tehran: Markaz-e Nashr-e Dāneshgāhī.
    34. Filmer, R. (1396). Pedarsālār yā Qodrat-e Ṭabī‘ī-ye Shāhān (A. Ardestānī, Trans.). Tehran: Negāh-e Mo‘āser.
    35. Qāzī Morādī, H. (1397). Dar pirāmūn-e khodmodārī-ye Īrānīyān. Tehran: Akhtarān.
    36. Karbān, H. (1384). Hekmat-e Eshrāq va Falsafe-ye Īrān-e Bāstān (A. Rūh-bakhshān, Trans.). Tehran: Asātīr.
    37. Kasravī, A. (1323). Sūfīgarī. Tehran: Āvā-ye Buf.
    38. Gardiner, H. W., & Kosmitki, C. (1399). Zendegī dar farhang-hā-ye mokhtalef: Ravān-shenāsī-ye tahavvol-e beyn-e farhangi (A. Mo‘tamedī, Trans.). Tehran: Dāneshgāh-e ‘Allāmeh Ṭabāṭabā’ī.
    39. Lambton, A. K. S. (1362). Mālek va zā‘er dar Īrān (M. Amīrī, Trans.). Tehran: Sherkat-e Enteshārāt-e ‘Elmi va Farhangī.
    40. Pahlavon, Ch. (1379). Nazariye-ye Dowlat dar Īrān (Ch. Pahlavon, Trans.). Tehran: Giyū.
    41. Naraqī, H. (1399). Jāme‘e-shenāsī-ye khodmānī (Cherā darmandeh-im). Tehran: Akhtarān.
    42. Nafīsī, S. (1391). Tārīkh-e ejtemā‘ī va sīyāsī-ye Īrān dar dowr-e mo‘āser. Tehran: Asātīr.
    43. Navā’ī, ‘Abdol-Ḥoseyn, & ‘Abbāsqolī Ghafārī-fard. (1403). Tārīkh-e tahavvolāt-e sīyāsī, ejtemā‘ī, eqtesādī va farhangī dar Īrān dar dowr-e Safavī. Tehran: Sāzmān-e Motāle‘e va Tadvin-e Kotob-e Dāneshgāhī dar ‘Olūm-e Eslāmī va Ensānī (Samt).
    44. Weber, M. (1398). Mafāhīm-e asāsī-ye jāme‘e-shenāsī (A. Sadāratī, Trans.). Tehran: Markaz.
    45. Hegel, G. W. F. (1398). Khodāygān va bande (H. ‘Enāyat, Trans.). Tehran: Khvārazmī.
    46. Høgeland, E. J. (1392). Zamin va enqelāb dar Īrān (F. Mohājer, Trans.). Tehran: Pardīs-e Dānesh.

     

Volume 2, Issue 2
September 2025
Pages 22-40
  • Receive Date: 28 September 2025
  • Revise Date: 18 October 2025
  • Accept Date: 15 November 2025
  • Publish Date: 23 September 2025